Inventing the Journalistic Narrative for the Electronic Environment
Robert Huesca
Trinity University
Summer 1999
Project Synopsis
The purpose of this project is to create materials for the World Wide Web that explain, critique, and showcase inventive examples of journalistic expression tailored for the new electronic environment. To achieve this purpose, I will conduct original research, create new instructional materials, and transfer and adapt existing work to digital formats that can be accessed via the World Wide Web. The material created during this fellowship will support an existing course, Reporting on/for the Internet, and will be incorporated into a submission to the open research competition of the Association for Education in Journalism and Mass Communication.
Rationale
The advent of the Internet and the exponential growth of the World Wide Web have created new opportunities and daunting challenges for communication professionals and educators. The World Wide Web has expanded the abilities of professionals to access information resources while providing new means of reaching readers, listeners and viewers. Yet the nature of new communication technologies themselves has created challenges and difficulties for practitioners and educators who are trying to understand their implications for theories and practices of information retrieval, organization, and delivery. A review of the existing literature in the field of journalism education and practice indicates that, by and large, neither intellectuals nor professionals have responded to these challenges in a critical, creative, or flexible manner.
Indeed, the introduction and rapid spread of Internet applications to the consumer market have sent academics and professionals scrambling to adapt to these changes in the information environment. Within the area of journalism education and practice, nearly all of the responses to the challenges posed by new communication technologies have called for the mere incorporation of the Internet, World Wide Web, telnet, and other applications into the existing norms and practices of journalism (Garrison, 1995; Huston, 1996; Ketterer, 1997; McGuire, Stilborne, McAdams & Hyatt, 1997; Reddick & King, 1997; Wendland, 1996). That is, for virtually all journalism educators and practitioners, new computer technologies represent tools to be applied to existing reporting and writing practices (see Fredin, 1997, for one of the few exceptions to this trend). Specifically, scholars and practitioners consider the Internet and its related applications as instruments that extend informational boundaries in terms of documentation and human sources that leave the essential mission and mode of journalism unaltered, as noted in Reddick & King (1997): "The more access to information reporters have, the better reporters will be able to fulfill their mission to inform the public about key issues and interests of the day. More access to more information can only lead to better journalism" (p. 4).
While journalism educators and practitioners have approached new communication technologies in an essentially conservative fashion--i.e. as tools to maintain the status quo--numerous scholars in the social sciences and humanities have suggested that these inventions herald fundamental shifts in social relationships, symbolic expression, cognition, and in reality itself (Bolter, 1991; DeKerckhove, 1995; Fredin, 1997; Jones, 1995; Landow, 1997; Mitchell, 1995; Turkle, 1995). That is, much of the research into new communication technologies suggests that conventional practices, such as journalism, at least need to be reconsidered and perhaps reinvented if they are to flourish in the new electronic environment. Of central relevance to this task is the work of various scholars who have focused on the implications of new communication technologies on the theory and practice of writing (Bolter, 1991; Fredin, 1997; Landow, 1997). Each of these authors has focused on the radical break from traditional narrative structures suggested both by the hypertext form and the convergence of audio, video, graphic elements, and written text. Bolter (1991) states the case most strongly, writing, "Today we are living in the late age of print. ...The printed book, therefore, seems destined to move to the margin of our literate culture. ...The shift to the computer will make writing more flexible, but it will also threaten the definitions of good writing" (p. 2). Similarly, the definitions of "good writing" and even conventional practice in journalism will undergo significant alterations due to changes wrought by the development of new communication technologies.
For two semesters (Fall 1996 and Fall 1998) I have taught a class at Trinity University that is driven by the central question, "What is the nature of the journalistic narrative in the new electronic environment?" Students have explored notions of the new journalistic narrative in a practical manner by reporting and writing in ways that reflect some of the ideas introduced in the literature noted above. This project intends to take this work to a higher level by supporting the creation of materials that will assist future explorations of the new journalistic narrative and engage the current scholarship in journalism education.
Specific Activities
During the period of support, I will carry out three major activities:
1) Conduct online research of efforts within journalism education and practice that attempt to forge new paths in the conceptualization and creation of narrative forms that break with convention. Research will include searches of the World Wide Web and databases compiled by the Communication Institute for Online Scholarship (CIOS). Past experience suggests that journalism--especially the commercial, mainstream outlets--has been slow to change in terms of presentational form. Nevertheless, journalism on the net today is significantly different from where it was two years ago, and this segment of the project will allow me to create materials that are up-to-date as of 1999.
2) Create a series of web pages that explain, critique, and feature student efforts to date at inventing journalistic projects that embrace notions stemming from the literature on new communication technologies. Student efforts currently exist on the web as separate "homepages." What this proposal will do is support the creation of web pages that integrate these separate works and provide a rationale and context for understanding them, as well as critiques of them.
3) Transfer textual and graphic materials currently used in teaching Reporting on/for the Internet to digital formats that will be more accessible to students and more illustrative of concepts that are central to the course. Once transferred, the materials will be used more effectively as tutorials, as they will contain links to reference materials and to exemplars of creative work conducted at Trinity University and elsewhere (as discovered in step 1 above).
Outcomes and Assessment
The materials generated from this project will contribute to my teaching and research. In teaching, the materials will be incorporated directly into the course, Reporting on/for the Internet when it is taught in the fall of 1999. The utility of these materials will be evaluated by the productive and creative capability of students taking the course in 1999. Their work will be compared to that of students who took the course prior to the development of online tutorials and critiques. Student evaluations of the materials will also form an important aspect of the overall assessment of the effectiveness of the materials.
In addition to the contributions to teaching, these materials will be incorporated into a research paper that will be submitted to the open competition of the Association for Education in Journalism and Mass Communication. The aim of developing this research is to have a significant impact on the direction of communication education, especially in applied fields such as journalism, public relations, and advertising. Including these materials in a research competition will add to their overall assessment as they will be examined by three blind reviewers and will be subject to a critical analysis by a panel discussant.
Qualifications of Applicant and University Support
I have taught rudimentary web authoring in the course discussed in this proposal, as well as in two other courses: Alternative Media (Spring 1995) and Web Publishing (Spring 1998). I have knowledge of a number of web authoring programs (Web Weaver, Page Mill, Netscape Gold, Netscape Communicator, Front Page) as well as raw HTML coding. I also am proficient with a number of supporting graphics programs including Photoshop, Canvas, Paint, MacPaint, and Imagemapper. Finally, I am knowledgeable of most Internet applications such as ftp, gopher, telnet, etc.
The university is fully equipped to support this project. The library's Instructional Media Services have several excellent slide and print scanners. The Department of Communication also has a print scanner, a digital still camera, and a digital video editor. From my office I have an ethernet connection to the Internet and to the university's server. My office computer is equipped with all of the necessary software except for Photoshop. Finally, the university is an affiliate with the Communication Institute for Online Scholarship, which will facilitate access to its databases.
References
Bolter, J. D. (1991). Writing space: The computer, hypertext, and the history of writing. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
DeKerckhove, D. (1995). The skin of culture: Investigating the new electronic reality. Toronto: Sommerville House Publishing.
Fredin, E. (1997). Rethinking the news story for the Internet: Hyperstory prototypes and a model of the user. Journalism & Mass Communication Monographs, 163.
Garrison, B. (1995). Computer-assisted reporting. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
Huston, B. (1996). Computer-assisted reporting: A practical guide. New York: St. Martin's.
Jones, S. G. (ed.). (1995). CyberSociety: Computer-mediated communication and community. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Ketterer, S. (1997). Teaching students how to evaluate and use online resources. Journalism & Mass Communication Educator, 52(4), 4-14.
Landow, G. P. (1997). Hypertext 2.0. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins.
McGuire, M., Stilborne, L., McAdams, M., & Hyatt, L. (1997). Internet handbook for writers, researchers, and journalists. New York: Guilford.
Mitchell, W. J. (1995). City of bits: Space, place and the infobahn. Boston: MIT.
Reddick, R., & King, E. (1997). The online journ@list: Using the Internet and other electronic resources, 2nd ed. Fort Worth: Harcourt, Brace & Co.
Turkle, S. (1995). Life on the screen: Identity in the age of the Internet. New York: Simon & Schuster.
Wendland, M. (1996). News in the next century: Wired journalist: Newsroom guide to the Internet. Washington, D.C.: Radio and Television News Directors Foundation.
Robert Huesca
Department of Communication
Trinity University
Phone: 210-999-8169
Fax: 210-999-8355
rhuesca@trinity.edu